The Causation Of The Civil War - 874 Words

The argument I will be discussing is what caused the Civil War, the fight over slavery or over states’ rights. Dew is going to be arguing that the South was fighting to protect their right to have slaves. Dew believes this partly due to the commissioners in the Deep South trying to rally people together to fight for the right to protect slaves. Gallagher will be arguing that actually the War was to preserve the Union. Gallagher believes this partly due to the most powerful symbol in the nation, the soldiers of the Civil War. It is possible that one could be right or both or neither could be right. My analysis will consist of me questioning the causation of the Civil War. Dew is a man who strongly believe that the southern secession was to protect slavery. He thought that the Deep South commissioners were against racial equality. The four Deep South states were Mississippi, Alabama, South Carolina, and Georgia; the commissioners were appointed by the governor (Dew, page 210). Therefore, the governor in a way was backing slavery to stay and to even expand it, which the commissioners were trying to do. They were trying to convince every state to fight for the right of slavery including the Border States. A critical point to make is that these commissioners were well-known public figures of the South, which helped to influence people. The commissioners were afraid of three things: racial equality, a race war, and racial amalgamation (Dew, page 212). Essentially, this fueledShow MoreRelatedInterpreting The Consequences And Causations Of The American Civil War1058 Words   |  5 PagesInterpreting the consequences and causations of the American Civil war is a complex and multifarious issue that is defined by two predominant archetypes, the revisionist and fundamentalist viewpoints. The multiple revisionist viewpoints emphasize different interpretations of the origins and significance of the Civil War such as a Southern constitutional viewpoint, politics, economics, sectional differences between the North and South, or the great slave power conspiracy. Moreover, while some of theseRead MorePurly Imaginative Subject by Gary J. Kornblith933 Words   |  4 Pagesresearch of causation. According to Kornblith, counterfactual exercises are necessary to â€Å"think more clearly about causation and to distinguish between essential factors and coincidental developments†(79). He uses the counterfactual method to present the idea that if Henry Clay had been elected in 1844, which he goes on to prove as plausible, we would be in a much different country. The thesis as a whole is stated as â€Å"†¦ My focus is on a different pair o f wars: the Mexican-American War of 1846-1848Read MoreAnalyzing The Severity Of Civil Wars By Bethany Lacina Essay1377 Words   |  6 Pages The article â€Å"Explaining the Severity of Civil Wars† by Bethany Lacina looks at why some civil wars are more deadly as compared to others by investigating a new data set that shows the number of combat deaths in civil wars from 1946 to 2002. The article looks at the statistics behind the deaths in the conflicts such as the era, the type of conflict ant the region that the conflict takes place in. The article also uses the strength of the state, the type of regime and cultural characteristics in aRead MoreEssay on The Raise of the West1226 Words   |  5 Pagesfor economic growth is the observation that the British economy grew rapidly from the late 17th century up to the late 18th century and beyond after the reduction in the monarch’s power following the victory of the parliament forces in the English Civil War in 1651. Thi s removed the monarch’s power to grant monopolies and also provided a relatively more free market in Britain. Along with historical evidences, contemporary studies have also appeared to support the argument that democracy can indeedRead MoreTheories Of The Common Sense960 Words   |  4 Pagescommon sense dictates that it is a choice to read this paper or even for this paper to be written at all. However, according to one form of early philosophy, common sense has led society astray. Each event that occurs throughout the universe has causation such that one never acts of his or her own free will. This theory of the absence of free will, known as hard determinism, has three main premises as its basis. The first premise states that no event is uncaused (Kleinman 64). This appeals to humanity’sRead MoreThe Origins Of The Great War999 Words   |  4 Pagesthe Great War, with WWI historiography going through many changes. Viewed as a fundamental turning point in global history, collapsing four empires in the process, it is not surprising to find that it is a fascination to both young and old still. Arno J. Mayer argues the case that domestic issues sweeping across Europe affected its foreign policies and stances, cumulating in the First World War. In Britain Irish civil war was brewing due to the support Carson and the UVF had from civil and militaryRead MoreDebate on Civil War1069 Words   |  5 PagesAmerican Historians’ Debate on the Civil War The American Civil War has without a doubt left a permanent divide on this great nation’s past and present. American historians still debate the causes of a war that began in 1861 between the Union states and Confederacy states. The war can be seen as caused by the principle of slavery, the growing tension between northern and southern ideology or due to a crack in the political system of the time. United States’ history classes focus on teaching studentsRead MoreThe Role of African-Americans in the Abolition of Slavery683 Words   |  3 PagesAfrican-Americans in the abolition of slavery According to Ira Berlins essay The role of African-Americans in the abolition of slavery, despite the role of slavery in causing the American Civil War, Northerners and Southerners alike did not envision slaves having a viable role in fighting for their freedom. However, as the war progressed, it became increasingly clear that slaves could play a role in the conflict to help the Northern side. The Emancipation Proclamation and the subsequent conscription of African-AmericansRead MoreThe Battle Of The Civil War1019 Words   |  5 Pagesprepare themselves for an all-out internal war. Both sides of this conflict grew from the same place. Despite the impulse to close ranks amid the culture wars, however, professional historians have not abandoned the debate over Civil War causation. Rather, they have rightly concluded that there is not much of a consensus on the topic after all. Most people believe that the Civil war was fought over the slavery enterprise, and they are partially right. The civil war did in fact have ties to opposition andRead MoreSlavery During The Civil War1159 Words   |  5 PagesThe Civil War, occurring between the years 1861 and 1865, was a devastating effect of sectionalism caused by the division of the country on the topic of slavery. Slavery impacted every aspect of the country, whether in the North or the South, though primarily in the South; major impacts were in the politics and economy of the early country ways which inevitably caused the Civil War. Slavery was the focal point of the economy in the South, this inthrallment was the fuel for the agricultural South